In a very close race all season long it seemed that Monsignor Martin would face West Seneca in the finals, barring any upsets. They were within a point of each other at any given time during the season. In the Inaugural season (2010-11) Monsignor Martin lost in the championship to Williamsville. It was a very intense game through all three periods.
West Seneca got on the board in the first period and the second stayed at 1-0. Action picked up in the third period as Julia Duquette put one in a 7:19 and then again at 12:11. Monsignor Martin shot 41 pucks at West Seneca Goalie Sydney Glynn and Monsignor Martin goalie Courtney Wesolowski stopped all 18 shots by West Seneca.*